I really like the remodeling job that the Fine Woodworking art directors did to my shop! I’ll have to put in a window like that next time.
If you can’t practice perfectly – and who can, when you’re just learning how to do something? – then there are two things you need to do. First, break down what you’re doing into easier, more fundamental tasks. And second, differentiate between practice and experimentation.
Break it down: If you can’t saw perfectly to a line, then work on your saw technique independently of cutting to a line. Having trouble with that? You can break it down even further. Make sure your grip on the saw is relaxed (like you’re holding a baby bird), that your wrist is straight, and that your forearm lines up perfectly with the back of the saw.
Make sure your stance is good, and your body is oriented correctly to allow your elbow to swing just past your hip. And practice the sawing motion with the power coming mostly from your shoulder. The saw stroke should be relaxed. It should sound relaxed. Long smooth strokes, with very little downward pressure. Let the saw do the cutting.
Once this is feels natural and you can get this feeling pretty much every time you pick up a saw (it shouldn’t take all that long), start in on the lines. But you can practice cutting to a line separately, too. Go to the bandsaw and practice there. It’s a great way to get comfortable with cutting exactly where you want to cut without having to think about all of the other body stuff. Then start to work on putting the saw technique and the lines together.
Try not to think about too many things when you’re learning something new; you can’t do it. Some of what you’re doing has to be turned into ‘muscle memory.’ The neural pathways have to be well established so your body can do the task right without expending much conscious thought. And that will allow you to think about the next element of the task; in this case, cutting to the line.
Practice vs. experimentation: You also need to learn to differentiate practice and experimentation. You’ll have to experiment with things – try out different grips, moving your body an inch this way or that, using more or less pressure. Pay careful attention to how things feel, and to what works and what doesn’t. You’re going to have to learn through experience just how much pressure to apply (not much), how to stand, how to get the saw started (even less pressure). so that you get the results you’re looking for. The key is to know what you’re looking for, so you can tell the difference.
More thoughts on this can be found in my new book, The Foundations of Better Woodworking. You can pre-order it here: http://www.shopwoodworking.com/foundations-of-good-woodworking-w8062
Want to start a woodworking argument? Start talking about cutting pins first or tails first for dovetails. And the funny thing is, it doesn’t matter. I’m not saying there aren’t reasons for choosing one approach over the other. But that’s not what’s going to determine your success or failure with dovetails. Of course, that’s not what we’re led to believe. “The best method,” “a new method,” or “so-and-so’s method” are supposed to make it easier. And so we try these new methods, or new tools, or whatever, in the hope of finally getting better.
Most of the time, searching around for the best method is just chasing around in circles. It doesn’t address what’s really keeping you from improving. In fact, it’s a serious distraction from working on what’s really important.
So what’s the secret? The same things that are important when cutting mortises and tenons; good saw and chisel technique, which in turn is based on proper body position and movement, and a strong concept of how the tools actually work with the wood. Also important are good layout and a really clear understanding of the lines. Beyond that, it’s just a set of instructions and a fair bit of practice.
These foundations of good work are the subject of my new book, which is currently at the printer, and expected to be out in early November (and first available at Woodworking in America). Or you can pre-order from: http://www.shopwoodworking.com/foundations-of-good-woodworking-w8062